All posts
6 min readAI video

What can’t AI video do yet?

itay rose ari · Creative director, AI filmmaker

Four things, in 2026: hold a human performance across a scene, keep weight and contact physically true, keep the proportions between objects real, and see the whole film instead of one shot. Each is fixed by the same human skill, cinematic language and editing judgment, which is why the human is still at the center.

How I think about this from inside the work, after about fifteen years making video and now building Tonpit.

01 · The center holds

Who still makes the video, if AI generates the shots?

The editor. Strip away the tooling and the human is still the source: the idea, the central motion that drives the whole thing, and the hand that ties it back together in the edit. I would go further and call this the era of the editor. The director of the edit.

What changes is the skill set. Editing always asked for a certain emotional and rhythmic intelligence, and, until now, a stack of technical ability to go with it. With AI in the loop, the technical part becomes a useful bonus, not a requirement. The editor turns into a director. A director with the rare ability to run a shoot day from the comfort of home.

A director who can run a whole shoot day from his living room.
02 · Where it still falls short

What are the four limits, and how do you work around each?

Performance, physics, proportion and cinematic language, and the workaround for each is the same skill, applied in the generation and in the edit. The limits are real, and naming them precisely is how you get past them. They share a tell: the result reads as off before you can say why. That is the uncanny feeling, and it is usually one of these.

Performance
Acting over time
Human performance is the Achilles heel. A model can surprise you with a single, startlingly precise take, but continuity of performance still slips. Until that closes, more generations and smart use of cinematic language carry you.
Physics
Weight and contact
Getting better fast, yet a clear uncanny edge remains when you watch closely. Cinematic language, and an edit that accounts for it, go a long way.
Proportion
Faithful relationships
Much improved, but you still get results where the relationships between objects are not true to reality, which quietly triggers the uncanny. Make checking for it a habit while you generate and it nearly disappears.
Cinematic language
Seeing the whole film
Models fall to a default. The default is often decent, because it leans on real references, but it misses the big picture of the whole piece, so you can end up with shallower cinematic language. Watch a few good breakdowns on it. You already understand the language intuitively, from a lifetime of watching.

There is a reason these cluster. A model predicts frames probabilistically. It holds no persistent sense of who a character is or how weight and contact behave, and it optimizes each clip on its own rather than the arc of the whole piece. That is why performance drifts, why physics wobbles, and why it defaults to safe, shallow coverage.

And notice the fix kept repeating. Performance, physics, proportion, language: the answer each time was the same, cinematic language and editing judgment. Every one of these limits resolves into a single human skill. That is not a coincidence. It is the whole argument.

03 · Where this goes

Will these limits go away?

Yes, probably all of them. I will be honest about the direction: I would not bet against any of these limits closing.

That does not shrink the human role. It relocates it. The person is still the one who brings the reason, the need, and the purpose the work is meant to serve. The steering stays human. It just rises a layer. As the technical floor falls away, what is left is judgment, taste, and knowing why you are making this at all.

The tools will close the gaps. The reason to make something stays ours.

Two short follow-ups coming on the crafts that do most of the heavy lifting here: holding consistency with image references, and cinematic language itself.